Incidence of
Chronic fever in Raigarh Development Block of Raigarh District, Chhattisgarh,
India
Oshin Bajrang1,*, Jitendra Kumar Premi2
1S.O.S in
Anthropology, Pt. Ravishankar Shukla University Raipur Chhattisgarh
2S.O.S
in Anthropology, Pt. Ravishankar Shukla University Raipur Chhattisgarh
Abstract
The present article is an empirical investigation of
the chronic fever in development block of Raigarh of Raigarh District
Chhattisgarh, India. Epidemiology is a branch of medical science that deals
with the incidence, distribution and control of disease in population. The
study aims to find out the incidence and distribution of chronic fever. In this
retrospective study, laboratory records of patients with chronic fever in
hospitals were reviewed. A retrospective study was carried out in various
government and private hospitals of development block of Raigarh. Purposive
sampling was used for the selection of chronic fever patients in present study
and for the collection of secondary data online journals and articles were
reviewed. Patients with enteric fever, malaria and dengue were observed. No
deaths were reported. Study concludes improved diagnosis for typhoid and
vaccination for prevention with enteric fever in Raigarh is needed.
Keywords: Chronic fever,
retrospective study, enteric fever, Raigarh
Introduction
Epidemiology
is a branch of science which deals with the incidence, distribution and control
of disease in population. Health plays fundamental role and vital in overall
development of individual, Health is fundamental to all and for overall
development in population and health plays vital role, epidemiological study is
population based study and John M Last has defined epidemiology that states
epidemiology is the study of the distribution and determinants of health
related state or event in specified population and the application of this
study to control of the health problem (Last, 1993). Under the epidemiological study, the distribution and
determinants all over population are included which helps the researcher to
identify core causes of health aliments (Gordis, 2014) , the findings of
epidemiological study and preventable measures when linked will provide
reducing prevalence and improving overall health outcome in study population
(Merrill, 2021). Retrospective studies make use of data that has already
been collected for the purposes other than research and retrospective case
series describes a number of cases with novel or uncommon illness or therapies
(Hess, 2004). Retrospective study is an important approach in medical research
to study the past cases and develop hypothesis for more investigation because
they have been helpful to determine pattern, connection and result by used
existing available data (Fukuhara H et al., 1990).
Objective
The
objective of the article is to explore the incidence of chronic fever among the
people of Raigarh Development Block of Raigarh District, Chhattisgarh.
To
know survival and mortality status of patient with chronic fever.
To
know the distribution of disease according to age and gender.
Materials
and methods
This
study was a retrospective study which includes 89 positive patients with
chronic fever from Sant Baba Guru Ghasidas Ji Memorial Hospital Government
Hospital of Raigarh development block from January to December 2022 through
purposive sampling. The selection criteria include all positive patients of all
age groups, with a confirmed diagnosis of typhoid, malaria and dengue in the
hospital, for the laboratory pathological test blood samples were used for
confirming chronic fever, and for the identification of typhoid specific
diagnostic test Widal test was used, malaria was identified through PV and PF diagnostic
test and Dengue was identified with RD and Elisa diagnostic test. The Inclusion
criterions include patients with all age group of year 2022, with typhoid,
malaria and dengue fever. Data was analyzed with SPSS 16.0 and for the
descriptive statistics such as mean and standard deviation were used to
summarize continuous variable.
Result
and discussion
The case distribution of various chronic
fever is represented in the form of various tables, in which (table no.1)
illustrates the distribution of three types of chronic fever – Malaria, Dengue
and Typhoid among the patients admitted in Sant Baba Guru Ghasidas Ji Memorial
Hospital Government Hospital of raigarh development block from January to
December 2022, here malaria accounts for 16.9% , Dengue represents 24.7% and
typhoid is the most prevalent , accounting for 58.4% . In the (table no.2 )
highlights the gender breakdown among chronic fever patients where males
accounts for 55.1% of the cases and female makeup 44.9% of the cases, here
males are slightly affected than females in study area, which might reflect
exposure to risk factor or access to healthcare services. In the (table no.3)
categorizes patients by age groups, range (21-40 years) are the most affected
groups, accounting for 35.95%, range (41-60 years) are second highest at
23.59%, range (1-20 years) represents 21.34% of cases, range (61-80 years)
accounts for 17.97% and range (81-100 years) are least affected only with
1.12%. In the (table no.4) shows the monthly distribution of cases, where in
June only 1.12% of cases were reported, July shows 12.35% of cases reported,
August shows 29.21% of cases reported and September was the peak with 57.30% of
cases reported. This data indicates chronic fever cases rises significantly
during the monsoon season in September. In the (table no.5), this table categorizes
the seriousness of chronic fever based on whether patients treated as
outpatients (OPD) or inpatients (IPD) here OPD males were reported 47.1% and
females were reported 37.07% and only a small proportion of patients with 7.86%
males and 7.86% females required hospitalization. In the (table no.6), this
table breakdown the seriousness of cases into outpatient department and
inpatient treatment across the age group, where younger patients(1-20 years)
had highest proportion of outpatient cases, while older groups (61-80 years) had
relatively higher hospitalization rates.
It is important to
note that no deaths were reported during the study.
Table No.1 Case
Distribution of various Chronic fever among the people of Raigarh Development
Block (C.G)
|
Chronic Fever
|
Pathological test for
confirmation
|
Sample for test
|
Percentage
|
Malaria
Dengue
Typhoid
|
PV and PF test
RD test kit and Elisa
test kit
Widal
|
Blood
Blood
Blood
|
16.9
24.7
58.4
|
Total
|
|
|
100
|
Table No.2 Gender
Distribution of Positive Patients with Chronic Fever
|
Gender of
Patient
|
Percent
|
Male
Female
|
55.1
44.9
|
Total
|
100
|
Table No. 3 Age Distribution of Positive Patients with
Chronic Fever
|
Age of Patient
|
Percent
|
1-20
21-40
41-60
61-80
81-100
|
23.59
35.95
21.34
17.97
1.12
|
Total
|
100
|
Table No. 4 Month of
Application of various Chronic fever cases among the people of study area
|
Month
|
Percentage
|
June
July
August
September
|
1.12
12.35
29.21
57.30
|
Total
|
100
|
Table No.5 Seriousness of Chronic Fever in Gender
|
Seriousness of
Chronic fever
|
OPD
|
IPD
|
Gender
Male
Female
|
47.1
37.07
|
7.86
7.86
|
Table No.6 Distribution of Seriousness of Chronic Fever in Age
|
Seriousness of
Chronic fever
|
OPD (%)
|
IPD (%)
|
Age
1-20
21-40
41-60
61-80
81-100
|
32
55
20.22
4.49
1.12
|
2.24
6.74
4.49
2.24
0
|
Discussion
Present
study reports mean age was 36 years for the patients of chronic fever and
majority of males patients were affected more. Study conducted in Jena
Winzerela, Germany on Q fever outbreak occurred in 2005 and in this study mean
age for sero-positive group were 53 years of age with confirmation of Q fever
infection in 2005 and 55 years of age for sero-negative group for household
members(Ankert et.al., 2022). Study conducted in Arizona on Valley Fever in
2019 its mean age was to be 50 years (Grizzle et.al., 2020). Study conducted on
Fever of Unknown Origin, by systematically reviewing patients demographics,
clinical symptoms, laboratory findings, imaging results and treatment outcomes
were helpful to indentify common cause of Fever of Unknown Origin(FUO), and the
mean age was not explicitly mentioned in this research (Petersdorf &
Beeson, 1961). Study conducted on Q-fever was essential for ensuring the
validity, reliability and ethical conduct of research and allowed for a
systematic investigation of Chronic Q Fever and Chronic fatigue syndrome and
study method help to leads to valuable insight into the long term effect of
Q-fever outbreak in Jena, Germany (Ankert et.al., 2022). The retrospective
method used in this study provides a comprehensive understanding of the
economic burden of the disease, estimating costs, analyzing data and informing
historical policy decisions and longitudinal analysis for improved healthcare
resources (Grizzle et.al., 2020).Researcher used retrospective study where
historical data and medical records of patients hospitalized with fever of
unknown origin between 1982 and 1988 were included and as a result
identification of diagnostic approaches, underlying causes, identification and
studying characteristics were possible, and as findings infection, collagen
disorder, neoplastic disorder, crohn,s disease and undiagnosed were found to be
the cause of fever of unknown origin and mean age was not described in this
research (Fukuhara H et.al., 1990). This article finds at least one typhoid
fever occurrence in 42 out of 57 African countries, and outbreak of typhoid was
increasing over time reported in 15 countries with both frequency and size,
method used in this study was retrospective which provides comprehensive
overview burden, trends and challenge of typhoid, and also for informing public
health intervention and the mean age was not explicitly mentioned in this
research (Kim et.al., 2019). Pattern found in present study and above mentioned
studies suggest need to explore preventive measures tailored to this critical
period and future studies should investigates the specific environmental
factors responsible for chronic fever.
Conclusion
The
incidence rate of Chronic fever in study area is 6.268, the mean age of the
patients with chronic fever is 36, Males are more affected than females,
patients age between 21 to 40 are more affected, patients age between 21 to 40
were admitted to Intensive care Unit, maximum patients were admitted in
September, No deaths were reported hence all patients were alive and typhoid is
maximum prevalent in Development Block Raigarh as compared to dengue and
malaria. Chronic fever remains a significant health burden in study area and
need of innovative health care solution to improve outcomes for study area.
Acknowledge
I would like to
acknowledge and my warmest tahnks to my supervisor Dr. Jitendra Kumar Premi who made this work possible. His guidance
and advice carried me through all the stages of writing my article. I would
like to thank the committee and staff of Sant
Baba Guru Ghasidas Ji Memorial Hospital Government Hospital, Raigarh for assisting me
to collect data regarding chronic fever.
References
Ankert,
J., Frosinki, J., Weis, S., Boden, K., & Pletz M. W. (2022). Incidence of
chronic Q fever and chronic fatigue syndrome: A 6 years follow up of large Q
fever outbreak. Transboundary and
Emerging diseases, 69(4), 2219-2226.
Fukuhara
H, Tamaki K, Nakamura H, Kanesima H, Irabu Y, Shimozi K, Shigeno Y, Kyinjou F,
& Saito A. (1990). A Retrospective Study of Hospitalized patients with
Fever of Unknown Origin(FUO) during six years. Kansenshōgaku Zasshii, 64(3),
335-341.
Gordis,
L. (2014). Epidemiology (5th ed.). Elsevier Health Sciences.
Grizzle,
A. J., Wilson, L., Nix D. E., & Galgiani, J. N. (2020). Clinical and
Economic Burden of Valley Fever in Arizona: An Incidence-Based Cost-of-Illness
Analysis. Open Forum Infectious Disease, 8(2).
Hess,
D. R. (2004). Retrospective studies and chart reviews. Respiratory Care, 49(10), 1171-1174.
Kim,
J. H., Im, J., Parajulee, P., Holm, M., Cruz Espinoza, L. M., Poudyal, N.,
Mogeni, O. D., & Marks, F. (2019). A Systematic Review of Typhoid Fever
Occurrence in Africa. Clinical infectious
diseases: an official publication of the Infectious Disease Society of America,
69(Suppl 6), S492-S498.
Last
J M. (1993). Dictionary of Epidemiology. CMAJ:
Canadian Medical Association Journal, 149(4), 400.
Merrill,
R. M. (2021). Introduction to Epidemiology (8th ed.). Jones
& Bartlett Learning.
Petersdorf,
R. G., & Beeson, P. B. (1961). Fever of Unexplained Origin: Report on 100
Cases. Medicine, 40(1), 1-30.