Lifestyle Modification Therapy and its
Effect on Weight Status of Non-Alcoholic Male Liver Disease Patients
Nafisha
Parveen1*, Nanda Gurwara2
1,2Govt. D.B. Girls P.G. College, Raipur (C.G.)
1nafisaparveen21@gmail.com, 2nandagurwara@gmail.com
Abstract:
This study examines the impact of
lifestyle modification counselling on the weight status of non-alcoholic liver
disease patients. To conduct the study 300 newly diagnosed male liver disease
patients were selected as samples and randomly placed into experimental and
control group. The study area of this study was the Raipur district of
Chhattisgarh. The standard anthropometric test was used for the assessment of
height and weight and BMI was calculated using a formula. Three months
counselling program was prepared based on the Fantastic Lifestyle Assessment
Checklist. Results reveal that in the pre-test assessment, 22.7% of male liver
disease patients lie in the normal weight category whereas after three months
of lifestyle counselling the percentage increased to 26.7%. In the pre-test
assessment of male liver disease patients in the control group, 12.7% were
normal weight and this percentage remained unchanged in the post-test
assessment. It has been reported that even slight weight loss due to positive
lifestyle changes improves the condition of non-alcoholic liver disease
patients hence the results of this study have magnanimous importance towards
the management of non-alcoholic liver disease patients.
Keywords: Life style modification, weight, liver disease, BMI.
INTRODUCTION:
The prevalence of liver diseases
in India is increasing and it has been considered as major public health
concern. The rise of liver diseases in India is higher than other Asian
countries especially China. In a developing country it is hard to get accurate
data on diseases and this hampers its management. However premature deaths and
physical/psychological disabilities associated with liver diseases is known and
its effect on economy and scanty healthy care resources needs no clarification.
The upwards trend of liver disease patients in India is due to adaptation of
western lifestyle along with sedentary habits Hence apart from diagnostic
measures and treatment of liver disease patients some behaviour modification
related with healthy habits are recommended. It has been opined that modifying
eating habits and physical activity status may be useful in better treatment
outcomes in patients suffering from liver diseases. It has been reported in
some studies that lifestyle modification is a sound method to reduce weight but
all these facts are scientifically not tested with regard to non alcoholic male
liver disease patients. Hence the present study was planned to study the impact
of lifestyle modification therapy and its effect on weight status of
non-alcoholic male liver disease patients.
Review of Literature
Parveen, N. and Gurwara, N. (2023) they discovered that
lifestyle counselling encourages better health-related behaviour through diet,
exercise, and limiting alcohol and tobacco use, which helps with weight
management for the treatment of cirrhosis in male patients. Pang et al. (2022),
Fernandez et al. (2022), Viveiros (2021), Lahelma et al. (2021), Katsagoni et
al. (2020), Mishra et al. (2020), Goyal et al. (2018), Anju and Shah (2017),
Mokdad et al. (2014), Sharma et al. (2008), Cohen and Kaplan (1979) conducted
studies on prevalence of liver disease in India, lifestyle modification for
liver disease patients and other allied issues.
Objectives:
(a) To assess the impact of three months
lifestyle modification therapy on weight status of newly diagnosed non alcoholic male liver disease patients.
(b) To assess
the impact of three months lifestyle
modification therapy on health related behavioural changes in newly diagnosed non alcoholic male liver
disease patients.
Hypothesis
1. Three
months of lifestyle modification therapy counselling will reduce the weight of newly diagnosed non alcoholic male liver
disease patients.
2. Three
months of lifestyle modification therapy will enhance healthy habits in newly
diagnosed non alcoholic male liver disease patients.
METHODOLOGY
Sample:
300 newly diagnosed non alcoholic
liver disease patients were selected from the Raipur district of Chhattisgarh.
These patients were enrolled in tertiary hospitals located in this area. The
age group of the selected patients was 35 to 55 years. Purposive sampling was
used for the selection of the sample.
Tools
Anthropometric measurements were
taken from standardized equipments while BMI was calculated by formula. FANTASTIC
lifestyle checklist was used to assess the effect of lifestyle modification
therapy on healthy habits. The lifestyle modification therapy of three months
was meticulously prepared based on factors given in the FANTASTIC lifestyle
checklist.
Design
This study uses a pre-post design.
Procedure
300 newly diagnosed male liver
disease patients were randomly placed in experimental (N=150) and control
(N=150) group. Experimental group received three months of lifestyle
modification therapy. The data was collected as per pre-post research design.
DATA ANALYSIS:
Table No. 1: Pre-Post
Test Frequency Distribution for BMI Status of Male Liver Disease Patients
BMI Categories
|
Experimental Group
|
Control Group
|
Pre-test
N(%)
|
Post-test
N(%)
|
Pre-test
N(%)
|
Post-test
N(%)
|
Underweight (<18.5 kg/m2)
|
-
|
-
|
01 (0.7%)
|
01 (0.7%)
|
Normal weight
(18.5-24.9 kg/m2)
|
34 (22.7%)
|
40 (26.7%)
|
19 (12.7%)
|
19 (12.7%)
|
Overweight
(25.0-29.9 kg/m2)
|
74 (49.3%)
|
75 (50.0%)
|
64 (42.7%)
|
64 (42.7%)
|
Obesity Class 1
(30-34.9 kg/m2)
|
32 (21.3%)
|
25 (16.6%)
|
40 (26.6%)
|
39 (26.0%)
|
Obesity Class 2
(35-39.9 kg/m2)
|
03 (2.0%)
|
03 (2.0%)
|
16 (10.7%)
|
17 (11.3%)
|
Obesity Class 3
(> 40 kg/m2)
|
07 (4.7%)
|
07 (4.7%)
|
10 (6.6%)
|
10 (6.6%)
|
Total
|
150
|
150
|
150
|
150
|
A perusal of table no. 1 reveals
some interesting facts about the experimental group. In the pre-test
assessment, 22.7% of male liver disease patients lie in the normal weight
category whereas after three months of lifestyle counselling the percentage
increased to 26.7%. Not much change was observed in the overweight category
with 49.3% of subjects classified in this category in the pre-test and 50% in
the post-test. In the pre-test assessment, 21.3% of male liver disease patients
from the experimental group were suffering from class 1 obesity while in the
post-test data this percentage was decreased to 16.6%. 2% of male liver disease
patients in the experimental group were suffering from class 2 obesity in the
pre-test assessment with no change in the post-test assessment. 4.7% of male
liver disease patients in the experimental group were suffering from class 3
obesity in the pre-test assessment with no change in the post-test assessment.
In the pre-test assessment of male
liver disease patients in the control group, 0.7% were underweight and this
percentage remained unchanged in the post-test assessment. In the pre-test
assessment of male liver disease patients in the control group, 12.7% were
normal weight and this percentage remained unchanged in the post-test
assessment. In the pre-test assessment of male liver disease patients in the
control group, 42.7% were overweight and this percentage remained unchanged in
the post-test assessment. The percentage of male liver disease patients in the
control group saw a slight change during the study period with 26.6% of
subjects being class 1 obese in the pre-test and 26.0% of subjects in the
post-test assessment. The percentage of male liver disease patients in the
control group was increased to 11.3% in the post-test as compared to 10.7% in
the pre-test for class 2 obesity. In the pre-test assessment of male liver
disease patients in the control group, 6.6% were suffering from class 3 obesity
and this percentage remained unchanged in the post-test assessment.
Table 2: Paired Comparison of Lifestyle
Modification Scores in Male Liver Disease Patients
Groups
|
N
|
Lifestyle
Modification
|
Mean
Difference
|
't'
|
Pre
Test
|
Post
Test
|
Mean
|
S.D.
|
Mean
|
S.D.
|
Experimental
Group
|
150
|
52.81
|
6.41
|
73.06
|
7.88
|
20.25
|
43.62
(p<.01)
|
Control
Group
|
150
|
51.68
|
6.19
|
51.27
|
6.71
|
0.41¯
|
0.54
|
t(df=149) at 0.05 = 1.98, t(df=149) at
0.01 = 2.60
A perusal of table 2 revealed that
the pre-test mean score on the lifestyle modification questionnaire of male
liver disease patients placed in the experimental group was 52.81 while the
standard deviation was 6.41. The post-test mean score on the lifestyle
modification questionnaire of male liver disease patients placed in the
experimental group was 73.06 while the standard deviation was 7.88. It means
that the post-test mean score on the lifestyle modification questionnaire of
male liver disease patients in the experimental group was significantly higher
as compared to their pre-test mean scores. t=43.62, p-value = .01) indicate
that the lifestyle of male liver disease patients in the experimental group was
significantly improved after the administration of 03 months of lifestyle
modification counselling. A perusal of table 4.37 revealed that the pre-test
mean score on the lifestyle modification questionnaire of male liver disease
patients placed in the control group was 51.68 and the standard deviation was
6.19. The post-test mean score on the lifestyle modification questionnaire of
male liver disease patients placed in the control group was 51.27 and the
standard deviation was 6.71. It means that there is no significant change in
the lifestyle of male liver disease patients in the control group after three
months of the study period as compared to their pre-test lifestyle trends.
(t=0.54, p value = not significant)
Results:
1. The percentage of male patients from
experimental group saw an increase in normal weight BMI category after three
months of lifestyle counselling.
2. The health related behaviour of male patients
from experimental group saw a significant improvement after participating in three
months of lifestyle counselling.
Discussion:
Results showed that the three
months of lifestyle modification therapy yielded a better management of weight
status of newly diagnosed male liver disease patients and the subjects of
experimental group also showed improvement in healthy lifestyle related factors
after study period. A study conducted by Virtanen et al. (2021) also reported
that one year of lifestyle counselling was beneficial for managing weight in
females with mean age of 48 years. It means that improving eating habits and
physical activity status can reduce weight and this is beneficial for liver
disease patients because it controls the excess liver fat.
Conclusion:
It may be concluded that even
slight weight loss due to positive lifestyle changes improves the condition of
non-alcoholic liver disease patients hence the results of this study have magnanimous
importance towards the management of non-alcoholic liver disease patients.
REFERENCES:
Anju, R.and Shah, K. (2017). Significance of
Sgot & Sgpt Ratio ( De Ritis Ratio) & Ggt Levels In Patients of Liver
Cirrhosis With And Without History of Alcoholism. Int J Res. Med., 6(2), 1-3.
Cohen, J.A. and Kaplan, M.M. (1979). The
SGOT/SGPT ratio--an indicator of alcoholic liver disease. Dig Dis Sci,
24(11):835-8.
Fernandez, T., Vinuela, M., Vidal, C. and
Barrera, F. (2022). Lifestyle changes in patients with non-alcoholic fatty
liver disease: A systematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS One;17(2).
Goyal, P., Goyal, O., Kaur, D. and Chhina,
R.S. (2018). Etiological Profile of Cirrhosis in a Tertiary Care Institute in
Northern India. Journal of Gastrointestinal Infections, January-December
2018;8(1):28-31.
Katsagoni, C., Papachristou, E., Sidossis, A.
and Sidossis, L. (2020). Effects of Dietary and Lifestyle Interventions on
Liver, Clinical and Metabolic Parameters in Children and Adolescents with
Non-Alcoholic Fatty Liver Disease: A Systematic Review. Nutrients 2020, 12(9),
2864.
Lahelma, M., Luukkonen, P.K., Qadri, S.,
Ahlholm, N., Lallukka-Bruck, S., Porthan, K., Juuti, A., Sammalkorpi H.,
Penttila, A.K., Arola, J., Orho-Melander, M. and Yki-Jarvinen, H. (2021).
Assessment of Lifestyle Factors Helps to Identify Liver Fibrosis Due to
Non-Alcoholic Fatty Liver Disease in Obesity. Nutrients,8;13(1):169.
Mishra, D., Dash, K.R., Khatua, C., Panigrahi,
S., Parida, P.K., Behera, S.K., Barik, R.K., Pradhan, S., Sahu, S.K., Thakur,
B. and Singh, S.P. (2020). A Study on the Temporal Trends in the Etiology of
Cirrhosis of Liver in Coastal Eastern Odisha. Euroasian J Hepatogastroenterol.
2020 Jan-Jun; 10(1): 1–6.
Mokdad, A.A., Lopez, A.D. and Shahraz, S.
(2014).. Liver cirrhosis mortality in 187 countries between 1980 and 2010: a
systematic analysis. BMC Med;18:145.
Pang, Y., Han, Y., Yu, C., Kartsonaki, C.,
Guo, Y., Chen, Y., Yang, L., Huaidong, D., Hou, W., Schmidt, D., Stevens, R.,
Chen, J., Chen, Z. and Li, J. (2022). The role of lifestyle factors on
comorbidity of chronic liver disease and cardiometabolic disease in Chinese
population: A prospective cohort study. www.thelancet.com, Vol. 28, 1-9.
Parveen, N. and Gurwara, N. (2023).
Health-Related Behavioural Counselling as a Remedial Measure for Cirrhosis
Patients, Journal of Survey in Fisheries Sciences, Vol. 10, Issue 4, 2708-2716.
Sharma, B., Marwah, R., Raina, S., Sharma,
N., Kaushik, M. and Kaushal, S.S. (2008). A study on the etiology of cirrhosis
of liver in adults living in the Hills of Himachal Pradesh, India. Tropical
Gastroenterology.
Virtanen, J., Penttinen, M., Kautiainen, H.
and Korhonena, P. (2021). The impact of lifestyle counselling on weight
management and quality of life among working-age females. Scand J Prim Health
Care. 2021; 39(3): 382–388.
Viveiros, K. (2021). The Role of Life Style
Modifications in Comprehensive Non-Alcoholic Fatty Liver Disease Treatment.
Clinical Liver Disease Journal, Vol. 17, Issue 1, 11-14.